Do Women and Men Lead Differently

Research Article

Do Women and Men Lead Differently, examines what large-scale 360-degree research and decades of academic study reveal about gender and leadership effectiveness. The article shows how women and men tend to lead in different ways, why those differences are often misread, and how organizations can build leadership pipelines based on demonstrated capability rather than inherited assumptions. Supported by the Women’s Leadership Skills-Training Course.

Why This Matters Now

Organizations are competing for leadership talent while trying to innovate, transform, and adapt faster than ever. In that environment, any bias that narrows the leadership pool or misjudges leadership quality carries a real performance cost. Yet women remain underrepresented as the organizational level rises, and the perception that women are less effective as leaders still shapes who is given opportunity.

The most widely cited evidence comes from leadership consulting firm Zenger Folkman. In 2011, it analyzed 360-degree assessments of 7,280 managers and executives, 64 percent men and 36 percent women, drawn from its Extraordinary Leader assessment. Each leader was rated on 16 competencies that differentiate the best leaders from average or poor ones, by managers, peers, direct reports, and others. On average, 12.7 raters evaluated each male leader and 13.1 raters evaluated each female leader. Jack Zenger and Joseph Folkman reported the findings in Harvard Business Review in March 2012.

The headline result was that there was no leadership-effectiveness deficit for women. On the overall leadership effectiveness index, built from 49 items tied to the 16 competencies, women were rated at 53 percentile points versus 49 for men. Women were rated more positively on 12 of the 16 competencies. The sample should be read with care: Zenger Folkman notes that its clients tend to be progressive companies with a strong commitment to leadership development, so the data is not a random sample of all leaders. The findings are strong evidence, but they are not a universal census.

Zenger and Folkman updated the work in 2019 with a larger body of 360-degree data, again finding that women were rated as effective as or more effective than men on most of the competencies measured, with men rated higher on two: developing a strategic perspective and technical or professional expertise. The consistency of the pattern across both analyses is what makes the signal worth acting on.

The Leadership Challenge

The leadership challenge is that the data on capability and the reality of opportunity point in opposite directions. In the 2011 sample, women held 22 percent of top management and executive positions, 32 percent of roles reporting to top management, and 39 percent of middle-manager and front-line supervisory roles, while they were 55 percent of individual contributors. Women were present in strength early in the pipeline and thinned out as the level rose. At the top management level, women were rated at 61 percentile points versus 52 for men, so the gap in representation was not explained by a gap in rated effectiveness.

Perception explains part of the problem. Because male leaders have historically been more prevalent, the behaviors many of them display have come to be treated as the definition of leadership itself. A leader who departs from that template can be judged as deviating from it rather than as leading differently. Social psychologists Alice Eagly and Steven Karau described this dynamic in their role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders: when the expectations attached to a leadership role conflict with expectations attached to gender, women can be evaluated less favorably as candidates and less favorably as incumbents, even when their performance is strong.

This produces a catch-22. Women are asked to prove capability before receiving the stretch assignments, visibility, and sponsorship that would allow them to demonstrate it. The perception persists because the evidence that would disprove it is harder to generate. Leaders who want a stronger pipeline cannot wait for the perception to correct itself. They must change the conditions that sustain it.

What Organizations Need to Understand

Organizations need to understand that the research supports two statements at once. First, women and men are rated as equally effective overall, with women rated higher on most competencies. Second, there are measurable tendencies in how leadership is practiced. These are not contradictory. Style differences are tendencies within groups that overlap heavily, not rules about individuals, and effectiveness does not depend on which style a leader uses.

The most rigorous evidence on style comes from a meta-analysis by Eagly, Johannesen-Schmidt, and van Engen, published in Psychological Bulletin in 2003. Reviewing 45 studies, they found that female leaders were more transformational than male leaders and engaged in more of the contingent reward behaviors that belong to transactional leadership, while male leaders were more likely to show management by exception and laissez-faire behaviors. The authors stressed that the differences were small. They also noted that the behaviors on which women scored higher were positively related to leader effectiveness, while those on which men scored higher had negative or null relationships to effectiveness.

This aligns with the pattern described in the practitioner literature. Many women lead in a participative, people-centered way: they set clear expectations, reward results, role-model desired behavior, and work to build the confidence of others. A more command-oriented approach, which gives direction, focuses on operational issues, and is goal-oriented, authoritative, and decisive, is more common among men. Both styles have a place depending on the situation. The risk is not that either style exists. The risk is that one is treated as the standard against which the other is measured.

The Zenger Folkman data also challenges common stereotypes. The expectation that women would be strongest in nurturing competencies such as developing others and building relationships proved partly true, but the largest gaps were elsewhere. Women were rated more positively on taking initiative (56 versus 48), practicing self-development (55 versus 48), displaying high integrity and honesty (55 versus 48), and driving for results (54 versus 48). Taking initiative and driving for results are often assumed to be male strengths. Men were rated higher on developing a strategic perspective, which Zenger and Folkman attribute largely to level: top leaders score highest on that competency, more top leaders are men, and when only top-management men and women are compared, the scores are comparable.

One finding deserves particular attention. In the competency of practicing self-development, which reflects how actively a leader seeks feedback and changes behavior in response, men and women start their careers on similar footing. Over time, women’s ratings pull ahead. The pattern suggests that continued learning and openness to feedback are habits that can erode with seniority, and that organizations should look at how they sustain them in all leaders.

The Enterprise Perspective

From an enterprise perspective, the question is not whether women or men are better leaders. It is whether the organization is converting its available leadership talent into leadership capacity. Research by Zenger Folkman links the competencies it measures to outcomes such as employee engagement, retention, customer satisfaction, and profitability. If those competencies are distributed across the workforce and the organization advances only a subset of the people who hold them, it is leaving performance unrealized.

The same lens applies to transformation. Organizations facing technology change, new operating models, and constant adaptation need leaders who can learn continuously, collaborate across functions, communicate with authenticity, and bring people along. The competencies where women were rated highest, including initiative, self-development, resilience, collaboration, and communication, are directly relevant to leading change. Women are not uniquely suited to lead transformation, and the research does not claim this. The point is that styles associated with participation, feedback, and inclusion are a strength in environments where adaptability and trust determine whether change takes hold.

McKinsey and LeanIn.Org’s annual Women in the Workplace research has documented where the pipeline breaks. Its recurring finding of a broken rung at the first step up to manager means that fewer women than men are promoted into the first management role, which compounds into underrepresentation at every level above. Fixing the pipeline later does not solve a problem that begins at the first promotion.

Self-assessment is another enterprise-level factor. In Zenger and Folkman’s 2019 analysis, women rated themselves lower than men on confidence, especially under age 25, with the two groups converging near age 40. Organizations that rely on self-nomination or self-promotion to identify high-potential leaders may overlook capable women whose ratings from others are strong. Selection systems that weigh 360-degree and demonstrated-performance evidence correct for this.

Where Performance Improves

Performance improves when organizations replace informal impressions with evidence. 360-degree data, structured talent reviews, and clear competency definitions allow leaders to evaluate people on observed behavior and results. Fair evaluation of leadership styles is part of that discipline: leaders should ask whether a behavior produces the outcome required, not whether it resembles the style of the people who held the role before.

Performance also improves when opportunity is distributed deliberately. Challenging assignments, visible projects, executive exposure, sponsorship, and stretch roles should reach capable women early in their careers, when the compounding effects on advancement are greatest. Recognition for successes should be explicit and attributed. These practices do not lower the bar. They remove the unequal access that makes the bar harder to clear for some.

Teams benefit from a broader range of leadership approaches. Command-oriented decisiveness is valuable in a crisis or when speed matters. Participative and developmental approaches are valuable when commitment, learning, and innovation matter. Organizations that cultivate range in all leaders, rather than assigning styles by gender, are better able to match approach to situation. Leaders of any gender can benefit from the habits the research highlights: seeking feedback, acting on it, taking initiative, and driving results with integrity.

Finally, performance improves when the organization measures progress. Representation by level, promotion rates at each step, assignment access, 360-degree results by group, and retention of high-potential leaders should be reviewed by senior leadership on a regular cadence. What gets reviewed gets managed.

Key Takeaway

Women and men do lead differently in some ways, but the differences are modest tendencies in style and emphasis, not differences in effectiveness. The best available evidence shows that women are rated as effective as men overall and rated higher on most leadership competencies, with men rated higher on strategic perspective and technical expertise. The larger problem is not capability. It is the perception, bias, and unequal access to opportunity that cause capable women to drop out of the leadership pipeline as the level rises.

Organizations that want stronger leadership should widen their definition of what effective leadership looks like, give capable women early access to challenging assignments and visibility, sustain feedback and self-development habits in leaders at every level, and base selection on demonstrated evidence. The objective is not to favor any group. It is to put the right people, regardless of gender, into leadership roles so they can do what leaders are meant to do: lead.

Extend the Insights

The intelligence developed by AMS subject matter experts is designed to help leaders turn performance ambition into operating discipline. The ideas explored across our research catalog connect directly to the advisory services, capability development, and learning experiences AMS provides. By extending these insights into AMS Advisory consulting solutions and AMS Academy training programs, organizations can strengthen capability, improve performance, and build the resilience required for sustained success. When your team is ready to move from insight to execution, AMS provides the expertise, structure, and support to accelerate that journey.

Join the ranks of leading organizations that have partnered with AMS to drive innovation, improve performance, and achieve sustainable success. Let’s transform together, your journey to excellence starts here.